N and I watched the last episode of season 2 of the BBC Robin Hood last night.
And both of us are left going “huh?”
In one episode they have done away with both strong female characters, and while I think what happened with Jaq and Will made perfect sense, what they did to Marian was just, well, again I say…Huh?
Guy of Gisbourn’s character has annoyed me for a while now. He’s one of the type of bad guy I really dislike, a bad guy with no real reason or motive for being bad. When Marian gave him a choice in this episode, to kill the sheriff & take his rewards from the king, and from her, who he has supposedly been pining for all this time, and for him to decide not to do so but then declare that he will take her by force…it’s all just badness for the sake of being bad. I didn’t see any motivation for him to choose the sheriff, who ridicules and mocks and mistreats him at every turn, who he can’t trust or turn his back on, over Marian offering to marry him willingly. The Guy who stayed behind with Marian when Nottingham was about to be razed just a couple of episodes back would have taken Marian’s offer in a heartbeat. His character just doesn’t make any sense.
It seems to me that the writers got this idea in their heads to have them marrying while she is dying, but didn’t really think past it for next season. What is Robin going to do without his Marian? Go all dark and broody ala bad Willow from Buffy? Become a playboy with a different girl in every village? Neither situation works for the character. And as I said earlier, that’s two great, strong female characters gone in one episode. Where are they going with this?